WoTReplays — Main

Link: Link copied to clipboard

Replay description

Replay's comments (30)

All replays

Replay link Download replay

Caught a cheater

Personal Score

Team Score

Detailed Report

374 times 4 30

Defeat

15 493

295

Live Oaks – Standard

Conqueror Gun Carriage

Red_Devil [WHO]

08.01.2015 20:10

	Without Premium	With Premium
Credits	10 329	15 494
Experience	197	295

Detailed Report

Statistics for Red_Devil

Play4Stats

Battle efficiency Σ: - 704 1 - 227 -

iulian_b AMX 50 100 1


{{ ::player.platoon }}		{{ ::player.username }}	{{ ::player.tank }}	{{ ::player.damageDealt }}	{{ ::player.frags }}	{{ ::player.xp }}	{{ ::player.achievements.length }}

{{ ::replay.translations.shots.fired }} {{ replay.detailedPerformance.vehicleShots }}
{{ ::replay.translations.shots.hits }} {{ replay.detailedPerformance.vehicleHits }}/{{ replay.detailedPerformance.vehiclePierces }}
{{ ::replay.translations.shots.heHits }} {{ replay.detailedPerformance. vehicleHeHits}}
{{ ::replay.translations.damageDealt.total }} {{ replay.detailedPerformance.damageDealt }}
{{ ::replay.translations.damageDealt.sniper }} {{ replay.detailedPerformance.sniperDamageDealt }}
{{ ::replay.translations.received.label }} {{ replay.detailedPerformance.vehicleIncomingHits }}
{{ ::replay.translations.received.pierces }} {{ replay.detailedPerformance.piercedReceived }}
{{ ::replay.translations.received.noDamage }} {{ replay.detailedPerformance.noDamageShotsReceived }}
{{ ::replay.translations.received.he }} {{ replay.detailedPerformance.heHitsReceived }}
{{ ::replay.translations.received.blocked }} {{ replay.detailedPerformance.damageBlockedByArmor }}
{{ ::replay.translations.friendlyFire }} {{ replay.detailedPerformance.vehicleTKString }}
{{ ::replay.translations.spotted }} {{ replay.detailedPerformance.vehicleSpotted }}
{{ ::replay.translations.damaged }} {{ replay.detailedPerformance.vehicleDamaged }}/{{ replay.detailedPerformance.vehicleKilled }}
{{ ::replay.translations.damageAssisted.label }} {{ replay.detailedPerformance.vehicleDamageAssist }}
{{ ::replay.translations.capture }} {{ replay.detailedPerformance.vehicleBaseCapture }}/{{ replay.detailedPerformance.vehicleBaseDef }}
{{ ::replay.translations.mileage.label }} {{ replay.detailedPerformance.vehicleMileage }}

Statistics

{{ ::replay.translations.shots.fired }} 1
{{ ::replay.translations.shots.hits }} 0/0
{{ ::replay.translations.shots.heHits }} 1
{{ ::replay.translations.damageDealt.total }} 704
{{ ::replay.translations.damageDealt.sniper }} 704
{{ ::replay.translations.received.label }} 1
{{ ::replay.translations.received.pierces }} 1
{{ ::replay.translations.received.noDamage }} 0
{{ ::replay.translations.received.he }} 2
{{ ::replay.translations.received.blocked }} 0
{{ ::replay.translations.friendlyFire }} 0/0
{{ ::replay.translations.spotted }} 0
{{ ::replay.translations.damaged }} 1/0
{{ ::replay.translations.damageAssisted.ownLabel }} 227
{{ ::replay.translations.capture }} 0/0
{{ ::replay.translations.mileage.label }} 0,34

Credits With Premium

Received	10 329		15 494

Fine for causing damage to allies	0		0
Compensation for damage caused by allies	0		0

Auto-repair vehicle	-32,444		-32,444
Auto-resupply ammunition	-2,450	0	-2,450	0
Auto-resupply consumables	0	0	0	0

Total:	-24,565	0	-19,401	0

Time

Starting time 20:10
Battle duration 7 min 48 s
Time of destruction 3 min 3 s

Experience

Version: 0.9.5
Server game time: 2015-01-08 20:10
Spawn: II
Battle type: Regular
Uploaded: Red_Devil

Look replay and tell me how he does this...

[edit 13-1-2015:]
This is how he did it:

Jan Novak Today at 15:12

Dear Red_Devil,

Thank you for contacting us.
Please note that it's not possible to see the vehicles that are not spotted. The spotting is being processed on the server-side and the information about the location of the vehicles that are not spotted at the moment is not being transferred to the client at all.
Having a detailed look on the battle replay and on our logs regarding the involved accounts, we have found that the enemy FV207 was playing from the very same location as one of the SPGs in your team, so it's very likely that the FV207 was simply looking on the screen of your own artillery and taking the arty positions from his screen (hence the accuracy).
So there is no need to be worried about any cheats, it's impossible due to the nature of the server-side processing of the game mechanics.

Thank you for your understanding.

Fine for causing damage to allies

#1 was he banned ?

erthemyoucell 2015-01-09 в 14:00
#2 next time be more specific as to what you are trying to show

jerry1014 2015-01-10 в 10:12
#3 if you had 6th sense you would know you were spotted, no cheats here and they aren't worth the time trying to hack server side system if even possible. Some body sneaked over to D6-7 area and lit you up, plain and simple. After 40k + battles you should know better then to call cheats.

jerry1014 2015-01-10 в 11:15
#4 jerry1014 , are you idiot ? look at mini map , who can spot that arty.. noone close to him and before him the arty killed other arty without spot..

erthemyoucell 2015-01-10 в 15:31
#5 Maybe you were camping in the obvious arty spots and that guy just guessed you were there and took a blind shot

Aurelian_rebels 2015-01-10 в 19:56
#6 Omg u cant cheat on this game

xJiM__x 2015-01-10 в 20:18
#7 @ Jerry dude I have full camo and sixsence. I have 3 skills on crew

Red_Devil 2015-01-10 в 23:25
#8 @Erthemyoucell, i dont know.

Red_Devil 2015-01-10 в 23:26
#9 lol i hope he get ban

Pulsus 2015-01-11 в 04:26
#10 Similar experience here, i was with my t-150 in Ensk i had 6th sense too, i was afk for like 10sec and started moving a lil bit and a su-5 suddenly hit me. Never spotted yet, was moving, in the very first minute of the game. I told my teammates to kill su-5 quick and fortunately our scouts killed him soon. There ARE some bs hacks. That kinda " this game is server based, it can't be hacked " is a pure bs. WG is just too lazy or too incompetent to detect and ban all the hack mods.

USSR_T34 2015-01-11 в 05:30
#11 and for some stubborn (or stupid) ppl like jerry or xjim above, note that fv207 scumbag killed m53/m55 first and then hits moving conqueror gc 3 times driving him to death, and finally kills m40/m43.. who can do this without any miss?? that fv207 is just a noob with some hack mods

USSR_T34 2015-01-11 в 05:51
#12 see that fv207 shot 5 did 3 direct fire and 2 splash which means literally no miss with arty.

USSR_T34 2015-01-11 в 05:53
#13 O-O I was sure there is no cheat in this game, but this was a cheat definately! Thats pretty nice that he is just so dumb to do it so open. If he would wait for a shot, everyone would think he is just a very lucky noob, wich get everyone on trasser....

hasilwasan 2015-01-11 в 14:23
#14 Looks like a random shot to me. Seems a lot of effort to hack and cheat for 1 kill.

beitou 2015-01-11 в 18:01
#15 At first I looked at this thinking that you were full of it. The first shot from the FV, sure, I could see that one. The next two were BS. So I have to agree he is using something that will get him banned.

GAIM3R 2015-01-12 в 01:56
#16 My guess is that driver of last surviving allied arty (M40/M43) was playing the game in the same room with FV207. No one else could provide good enough view to allow for such precision. They were two friends chilling together shooting with some arties and they got lucky (to get in game together) and immediately exploited opportunity to "have some fun".

SirMushy 2015-01-12 в 09:56
#17 yep, maybe it was 1 player with 2 clients, countdown, lucky in same battle. I dont beleave in cheats like nofog :)

Plastilin 2015-01-12 в 11:36
#18 i mean hitting u once in the open is luck ok...that might go thru....but after you drove backwards ... it is simply impossible that he randomly hits u again ....no no...cheats!

MasterEraserCoH 2015-01-12 в 14:03
#19 yes, did u even read comments 16 and 17? guess not, but yes, It HAVE to be a cheat, nothing else is possible...

Plastilin 2015-01-12 в 21:28
#20 I asked him, he say it was pure luck, If that is true he will win lottey. Plastilin (19:42:34) hi Plastilin (19:42:41) what you say to this replay? http://wotreplays.com/site/1506668#live_oaks-red_devil-conqueror_gun_carriage Plastilin (20:08:08) helllo? Piwosz1302 (20:13:23) no english Plastilin (20:17:55) co powiesz na ten replay? czy oszukiwać? Plastilin (20:23:09) co powiesz na tą powtórkę? Piwosz1302 (20:23:30) be lucky Plastilin (20:23:37) you did 5 shots Plastilin (20:23:45) 5 shots, 3 kills Plastilin (20:24:08) blind Plastilin (20:25:39) did you play with 2 accounts? 2 screens? Piwosz1302 (20:27:41) no shots blind Plastilin (20:28:17) you dont lie? u should try play lottery then, u will win jackpot Piwosz1302 (20:29:34) yes

Plastilin 2015-01-12 в 22:38
#21 kriki66[P4IN] and Templarte[P4IN] are on your team a platoon of WT aufe pz4 and E 75. etane_[P4IN] and orangebeuz[P4IN4] are on the enemy team, playing E5 and Maus. This is simply cheating in other way tho. They were 99% on team speak or other communication program, and since they met in battle they 99.9% gave your positions. No one was even close to spotting you. So that must be it. And those guys deserve a few days ban for unsportsmanlike conduct. Pretty unfair and cheap play by those guys.

Himmelfallen 2015-01-13 в 11:20
#22 Actually I am begining to think they had nothing to do with it, and that the other arty was really using something to cheat.

Himmelfallen 2015-01-13 в 11:27
#23 well i watched this few time and in my opinion there was no cheats...1.there is a small chance that PantherII somehow spoted him....2.maybe it was Leo in watter but thats wierd....but what i think after watching it from every angle i could find its very simple,he just trace u and when u moved ur BIG arty he trace u again cuz he play on very very high detail and when u do that the tracks leave a small trace behind ur tank....and yes btw u dont have camo on that BIG arty so think twice before u call someone hacker and yes he was very lucky...anyway i wish u good luck:)

UnholySoul 2015-01-13 в 16:15
#24 @xJiM__x dude, if its on a computer it can be edited. you can cheat at anything virtual!!! get it through your head. also, "banned mods" are conciderd cheats beacuse they edit a game in an un fair way. and a "banned mod" can be easly downloaded. excuse the spelling, im a retard.

Soal_Fox 2015-01-14 в 00:05
#25 I got answer from WG: Jan Novak Today at 15:12 Dear Red_Devil, Thank you for contacting us. Please note that it's not possible to see the vehicles that are not spotted. The spotting is being processed on the server-side and the information about the location of the vehicles that are not spotted at the moment is not being transferred to the client at all. Having a detailed look on the battle replay and on our logs regarding the involved accounts, we have found that the enemy FV207 was playing from the very same location as one of the SPGs in your team, so it's very likely that the FV207 was simply looking on the screen of your own artillery and taking the arty positions from his screen (hence the accuracy). So there is no need to be worried about any cheats, it's impossible due to the nature of the server-side processing of the game mechanics. Thank you for your understanding. So no illegal mods....

Red_Devil 2015-01-14 в 01:21
#26 THIS IS NO CHEAT !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! does really no one sees that there is a platoon from P4IN in your team and in the enemy team? They just pressed start on the same time, and giving positions away through teamspeak!! So easy,...

markbenq 2015-01-14 в 01:38
#27 I can believe that it is a cheat. Look at the battle, look at the team score - he killed all enemy artys with CLEAN shots. But I'm not wondering that WG tell you lot of pretext.

Innosgesandter 2015-01-14 в 02:13
#28 i am starting to think about it aswell,.... (after i watched the entire replay), i mean the last shot on him was exactly!!! on the same spot (in the middle of his tank) U might want to put this on FTR if u want do something about it, i dont think WG will watch the replay and just send u a (almost) automatic e-mail.

markbenq 2015-01-14 в 02:21
#29 guys, do u even read? read the edits of red devil or read previous post like #16, #17 and #25 ? think u dont, or u dont wanna understand and keep beleaving in ur cheating no fog theory and keep telling bullshit and doing laughable comments without any clue. this is how conspiraty theorys starts. serious...

Plastilin 2015-01-14 в 09:38
#30 Looking on his mate screen is in my opion still cheating. Thats why I dont edit/delete replay.

Red_Devil 2015-01-14 в 13:02